Continued from: West Pillar (Regular Variation) (III, 5.9, 5P)
Stefan Suter and I climbed the W Pillar Direct (III, 5.10b, 5P) car-to-car. I led P2 (5.8) & P3 (5.10b) and Stefan led the rest (P1@5.9, P4@ cl.4-5, P5@5.9). This time we took the P5 5.9 OW finish, which climbed a cool flare behind a detached flake. I followed both the 5.9 offwidths on P1 & P5 without dropping my pack on a leash to keep it sporty. Great climb!
Stefan leading P1 (5.9). He is at the 5.8 OW.
Stefan leading P1 (5.9). He is at the 5.8 OW.
Stefan leading P1 (5.9). He is at the 5.9 OW crux. This can also be stemmed.
It was interesting to follow P1 this time instead of leading it, as I could experiment more with less trepidation of falling. I found both the 5.8 and 5.9 OW to be much easier, so much that I left my pack on (I trailed it when I led it in January). The 5.8 crux can be stemmed and face climbed on the right just fine, and the 5.9 crux can be nicely stemmed while staying deep enough in to place or clean pro. The only OW moves I did this time were camming my legs in the crack as I moved over the top. If you climb the 5.9 as an OW, left-side in tends to be better. If stemming, right side in is better due to the lean and better holds on the left face.
Stefan atop P1. The strange double cracks of P2 are above.
Strange double or triple cracks of P2 (5.8)
Pitch 2 was really fun, and the multitude of cracks got me switching around to follow the best line. I stopped about 30 ft short of the piton belay indicated in SuperTopo as I heard that it was better to do so since the 5.10b crux is essentially right on top of that belay. I made a semi-hanging anchor on a sloping ledge.
Upper part of P2. Stop at a sloping ledge for a semi-hanging belay short of the high corner. The highest corner, indicated in ST as the belay, is nicer to belay but the crux of P3 is then right on top of the belay.
Leading up P3, looking at the 5.10b crux section.
This is the view from the lower anchor. The bit above is a lot thinner and harder than lower down, and would be the crux of the pitch if you go all the way to the SuperTopo belay. I'd call it 5.8+ or even 5.9-.
P3 5.10b lieback crux section.
I found the crux surprisingly scary. It is so close to the belay ledge that it is hard not to accidentally step on the anchor piton. I'm not much of an 'arms' guy, so I suck at liebacks and this one really worked me.
I placed a #2 Metolius cam to start, and another body length up I slammed in an awkward and strenuous fist jam and threw in a #3 Camalot. The flare behind the block made the cam set funky with the top lobes being a bit too wide, but it was strenuous enough to hang where I was that I decided to race up to what looked like a good rest spot and place another piece instead of fiddling with this one.
I climbed up a ways only to find no good rest! Now it felt like I might risk falling if I hung out to place gear, but there appeared to be a good rest/gear placing stance a bit higher.
I climbed up further only to find no good rest! Crap - now I'm high enough that I would deck even if the #3 Camalot held. I was getting concerned but decided at this point to still climb a bit higher and finally sunk a bomber hand jam with a good stem. I threw in a 'thank god' cam and stepped right to finish the pitch. Whew!
P4 (cl. 4-5). First half is cl. 2-3 & very easy.
This time I think we found the easiest way to climb P4. Done this way, it follows the crest more closely and is cl. 4 (or a generous cl. 5). Just traverse the high blocks (cl. 3-4), aiming for the small tower split with vertical cracks. Place a piece in the cracks and step right, and make a few cl. 4 mantels to the top. From there it is cl. 3 to a nice belay on a sloping ledge in the corner below the next pitch.
Add annotated picture of P4&5 Stefan on P4 (cl. 5). You can clearly see the detached flake forming the 5.9 OW variation to the left.
Stefan leading the beginning of P5.
Stefan on P5 starting into the 5.9 OW-flare behind the detached flake. The 5.8 'rib wrestling' variation continues left of the flake just below him.
Whether you climb it with stemming or staying inside the flare, the crack seems best approached left-side in.
Stefan leading the P5 5.9 OW-flare variation.
Following the P5 5.9 OW-flare variation, which goes behind the detached flake above. This section was short but very cool!
I found that if you avoided stemming and attempted this section facing in, it was pretty reasonable to climb with a pack. Sink a deep fist jam, press with the other hand, throw in a leg, and heel-toe with the outside foot to adjust the ratchet and up you go!
The upper section of P5. Exposed but very easy.
Stefan rappelling off Eichorn Pinnacle.
For leading either variation nothing smaller than a 0.3 Camalot or #1 Metolius is needed (#1 or #2 C3s can be helpful on the P1 crux). Also, doubles through #3 Camalot should allow one to climb comfortably. A #4 Camalot could be placed on P1 but is very optional. The P5 OW variation is protected just fine with #2 & #3 Camalots, though a #4 could optionally be placed too.